The Ultimate Guide to the Best Countertop Material For Your Kitchen
Columbus, OH

The Ultimate Guide to the Best Countertop Material For Your Kitchen

Columbus, OH

The Ultimate Guide to the Best Countertop Material For Your Kitchen


Get free estimates for your project or view our cost guide below:

Get free estimates for your project or view our cost guide below:
Are you a pro? Get new customers
Tamatha Hazen
Written by
Tamatha Hazen
Edited by
Tara Farmer
Fact-checked by
Kristen Cramer

Picking the right countertop material is one of the most exciting and important parts of your kitchen remodel! Since most people keep their countertops for a decade or more, it's important to choose something you love. In this guide, we'll explore some popular options and share tips on how to choose the best countertop material for your kitchen.

What is the best material for countertops?

When choosing the best material for your kitchen countertops, consider factors like lifestyle, durability, and maintenance. Think about how you use your kitchen. If you cook frequently or entertain often, you'll want a surface that is both durable and easy to care for. Now, let's explore some popular countertop materials to find the right fit for you.

Quartz

Quartz countertops combine the beauty of natural stone with the durability of engineered materials. Made from crushed quartz mixed with resin, they offer a non-porous surface that resists stains and bacteria. Quartz is low-maintenance, available in a wide array of colors and patterns, and doesn't require sealing like natural stones do. It's a great choice for busy kitchens!

A kitchen with quartz countertops in two coordinating patterns
A kitchen with quartz countertops in two coordinating patterns

Granite

Granite countertops are popular for their durability and timeless elegance. Each slab is unique, boasting its own patterns and colors that can elevate any kitchen design. They're heat-resistant and scratch-resistant, making them ideal for cooking enthusiasts. With proper sealing and maintenance, a granite countertop can last for decades, providing both beauty and functionality.

A kitchen with granite countertops, custom cabinets with glass-front doors and interior lighting, and luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring
A kitchen with granite countertops, custom cabinets with glass-front doors and interior lighting, and luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring

Marble

Marble countertops exude luxury and sophistication with their stunning veining and rich colors. While they are softer than granite, making them more susceptible to scratches and stains, their high-end look is hard to beat. Marble works beautifully for baking due to its cool surface, but regular sealing is essential to keep marble looking its best.

A modern farmhouse-style kitchen with marble countertops, white and gray cabinets, and stainless steel appliances
A modern farmhouse-style kitchen with marble countertops, white and gray cabinets, and stainless steel appliances

Butcher block

Butcher block countertops bring a warm, rustic charm to any kitchen. Made from strips of wood glued together, they offer a beautiful, natural aesthetic while being functional for food preparation. Their durability is impressive, but they do require regular oiling to maintain their appearance. If you love cooking, a butcher block countertop can be a delightful addition to your culinary space.

Kitchen with butcher block counters, white cabinets, and natural brick backsplash
Kitchen with butcher block counters, white cabinets, and natural brick backsplash

Laminate

Laminate countertops are a budget-friendly option that doesn't skimp on style. Available in countless colors and patterns, they can mimic the look of more expensive materials like granite or marble. They're easy to clean and maintain, making them perfect for busy households. However, while laminate is resistant to stains, it can be prone to scratches and heat damage.

Kitchen with Formica laminate counters in Argento Romano and Paloma Dark Grey colors.
Kitchen with Formica laminate counters in Argento Romano and Paloma Dark Grey colors.

Solid surface

Solid surface countertops offer seamless designs that are both stylish and functional. Made from acrylic or polyester materials, they come in various colors and patterns that mimic natural stone. They're easy to clean and repairable if scratched or damaged. Solid surface countertops are perfect for modern kitchens where aesthetics and practicality go hand in hand.

A kitchen island with solid surface countertops made by Wilsonart.
A kitchen island with solid surface countertops made by Wilsonart.

Stainless steel

Stainless steel countertops are the go-to choice for professional kitchens due to their durability and hygienic properties. They resist heat, stains, and bacteria while providing a sleek, modern look. Although they scratch easily, many chefs appreciate the ruggedness that comes with use over time. Stainless steel is perfect for those who value functionality that doesn't sacrifice style.

Kitchen island with stainless steel countertop.
Kitchen island with stainless steel countertop.

Soapstone

Soapstone countertops bring a unique charm with their soft feel and rich colors ranging from gray to green. This natural stone is heat-resistant and non-porous, making it ideal for kitchen use. While it can scratch easily, these marks can often be sanded out for a fresh look. Soapstone's rustic appeal makes it a favorite among those seeking a distinctive countertop option.

Kitchen with soapstone countertops, white cabinets, and a modern matte black range hood.
Kitchen with soapstone countertops, white cabinets, and a modern matte black range hood.

Concrete

Concrete countertops provide an industrial yet chic look that can be customized in color and texture. Concrete also allows for unique shapes and designs. This versatile material is incredibly durable and heat-resistant but requires sealing to prevent stains. With proper care, concrete countertops can become a stunning centerpiece in any kitchen.

A modern kitchen with concrete countertops.
A modern kitchen with concrete countertops.

Onyx

Onyx countertops are truly eye-catching with their translucent quality that allows light to shine through. This natural stone offers vibrant colors and unique patterns that make each piece one-of-a-kind. However, onyx is softer than other stones, so it requires careful handling to avoid scratches or damage. It's an excellent choice for those looking to make a bold statement in their kitchen design!

Kitchen island with green onyx countertops.
Kitchen island with green onyx countertops.
Get free estimates from countertop installers near you.

Countertop material cost comparison

A new countertop can transform your kitchen from ordinary to extraordinary! With so many materials available, it's essential to find one that fits your budget, style, and needs. The table below offers a quick overview of average installed costs and the pros and cons of our best countertop materials.

Best countertop materials comparison
Material Average installed cost per square foot Pros Cons
Quartz $50 – $200
  • Low maintenance
  • Wide variety of colors
  • Can be pricey
Granite $80 – $150
  • Durable
  • Classic aesthetics
  • Requires sealing
  • Heavy
Marble $40 – $150
  • Elegant look
  • Great for baking
  • Prone to staining
  • Requires maintenance
Butcher block $50 – $150
  • Warm, natural surface
  • Great for cooking
  • Requires maintenance
  • Vulnerable to heat and moisture
Laminate $20 – $80
  • Affordable
  • Stylish options
  • Less durable
  • Prone to heat and scratches
Solid surface $50 – $150
  • Seamless design
  • Less heat resistant
Stainless steel $80 – $200
  • Sleek, hygienic
  • Heat resistant
  • Scratches easily
  • Can feel cold
Soapstone $60 – $130
  • Unique, rustic charm
  • Softer; prone to scratches
Concrete $50 – $150
  • Customizable
  • Can crack
  • Requires sealing
Onyx $50 – $200 per SF
  • Stunning visuals
  • Expensive, fragile

Getting estimates from countertop installers

Once you've narrowed down your options and decided on the material that best fits your needs and budget, the next step is to find a qualified countertop installer who can bring your vision to life. Here are some tips to help:

  • Get at least three estimates from different contractors to compare prices and services effectively.

  • Ask about the installation methods each contractor uses, as this can influence both cost and quality.

  • Ensure that the estimate includes a detailed breakdown of all costs, such as materials, labor, removal of old countertops, and any additional features like cutouts or backsplashes.

  • Inquire about any potential hidden fees that may arise during the installation process.

  • Confirm the estimated timeline for the project to ensure it fits your schedule.

  • Check the contractor's licensing, insurance, and reviews from previous clients to ensure reliability.

  • Inquire about warranties on both materials and workmanship for added peace of mind.

  • Pay attention to how responsive each contractor is during the quoting process; good communication is crucial for a successful project.

Questions to ask a countertop installer

When meeting with countertop installers, ask these questions to find the right contractor for your project:

  • What is included in the cost estimate?

  • What types of materials do you offer?

  • Can I view the slabs before installation?

  • Are you accredited or certified?

  • Who will handle the plumbing or electrical work?

  • What is the estimated timeline for installation?

  • How do you handle repairs if damage occurs?

  • What is your experience with installing my chosen material?

  • Can you provide references or examples of previous work?